All national & international child welfare guidelines emphasize Best Interest

…but the new ICWA regulations deny children a best interest hearing.

The new Bureau of Indian Affairs guidelines for Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) implementation disallow a best-interest hearing in child welfare cases involving Indian American children, assuming that the best interest is always with the tribe. In contrast, all major child welfare guidelines emphasize the primacy of the best interest standard. The Hague Convention, the United Nations, the American Psychological Association, and the National Association of Social Workers’ guidelines are included here.

The American Psychological Association guidelines indicate that children, parents and the state all have interests in child welfare investigations. The first guideline emphasizes that the child’s best interest is the primary purpose of an evaluation.

Guideline 1: The primary purpose of the evaluation is to provide relevant, professionally sound results or opinions in matters where a child’s health and welfare may have been and/or may be harmed.

The UN convention on the Rights of the Child argues that the best interests of children “must be the primary concern in making decisions that may affect them” (Article 3).

Non-discrimination (Article 2): The Convention applies to all children, whatever their race, religion or abilities; whatever they think or say, whatever type of family they come from. It doesn’t matter where children live, what language they speak, what their parents do, whether they are boys or girls, what their culture is, whether they have a disability or whether they are rich or poor. No child should be treated unfairly on any basis.

Best interests of the child (Article 3): The best interests of children must be the primary concern in making decisions that may affect them. All adults should do what is best for children. When adults make decisions, they should think about how their decisions will affect children. This particularly applies to budget, policy and law makers.

The National Association of Social Workers emphasize that client well-being is the social worker’s first responsibility.

“Services are intended to protect children and their well-being, strengthen families, and provide permanency when children cannot safely remain with their families. Child welfare services should be strength based; family centered; trauma informed; and respectful of a family’s culture, values, customs, beliefs and needs.”

The United Nations Guidelines for Children in Alternative Care emphasize dignity and respect for children, stability, permanency and safety. They specifically mention the best interests of the child 25 times. A key portion states that:

11 All decisions concerning alternative care should take full account of the desirability, in principle, of maintaining the child as close as possible to his/her habitual place of residence, in order to facilitate contact and potential reintegration with his/her family and to minimize disruption of his/her educational, cultural and social life.

12 Decisions regarding children in alternative care, including those in informal care, should have due regard for the importance of ensuring children a stable home and of meeting their basic need for safe and continuous attachment to their caregivers, with permanency generally being a key goal.

13 Children must be treated with dignity and respect at all times and must benefit from effective protection from abuse, neglect and all forms of exploitation, whether on the part of care providers, peers or third parties, in what- ever care setting they may find themselves.

14 Removal of a child from the care of the family should be seen as a measure of last resort and should, whenever possible, be temporary and for the shortest possible duration. Removal decisions should be regularly reviewed and the child’s return to parental care, once the original causes of removal have been resolved or have disappeared, should be in the best interests of the child, in keeping with the assessment foreseen in paragraph 49 below.

15 Financial and material poverty, or conditions directly and uniquely imputable to such poverty, should never be the only justification for the removal of a child from parental care, for receiving a child into alternative care, or for pre- venting his/her reintegration, but should be seen as a signal for the need to provide appropriate support to the family.

The Hague Convention makes very clear that a child’s best interest is the fundamental consideration in child welfare decisions. 

Article 1 (a) to establish safeguards to ensure that intercountry adoptions take place in the best interests of the child and with respect for his or her fundamental rights as recognized in international law;

“Convinced of the necessity to take measures to ensure that intercountry adoptions are made in the best interests of the child and with respect for his or her fundamental rights, and to prevent the abduction, the sale of, or traffic in children…”

4b) have determined, after possibilities for placement of the child within the State of origin have been given due consideration, that an intercountry adoption is in the child’s best interests;

16d) determine, on the basis in particular of the reports relating to the child and the prospective adoptive parents, whether the envisaged placement is in the best interests of the child.

Article 21 (1) Where the adoption is to take place after the transfer of the child to the receiving State and it appears to the Central Authority of that State that the continued placement of the child with the prospective adoptive parents is not in the child’s best interests, such Central Authority shall take the measures necessary to protect the child, in particular –

Article 24

The recognition of an adoption may be refused in a Contracting State only if the adoption is manifestly contrary to its public policy, taking into account the best interests of the child.

The BIA should ensure that ICWA guidelines comply with these international and national standards by assuring each Indian American child’s best interest will be heard in court.

Bonnie F. Cleaveland, PhD ABPP

Clinical Psychologist

Charleston, SC


APA Guidelines

Hague Convention text

NASW Standards

UN Guidelines


American Psychological Association (2013). Guidelines for psychological evaluations in child protection matters. American Psychologist 68(1) 20-31. Retrieved from

Hague Conference on Private International Law (1993). Hague Convention on Protection of Children and Co-operation in Respect of Intercountry Adoption. Retrieved from

National Association of Social Workers (2012). NASW Standards for Social Work Practice in Child Welfare. Retrieved from

United Nations (2012). Guidelines for the alternative care of children. Retrieved from

United Nations (1990). Convention on the rights of the child. Retrieved from

836 thoughts on “All national & international child welfare guidelines emphasize Best Interest

  1. Pingback: cialis 20
  2. Pingback: generic cialis
  3. Pingback: cialis
  4. Pingback: Cost viagra
  5. Pingback: Sale viagra
  6. Pingback: cost of cialis
  7. Pingback: is cialis generic
  8. Pingback: cialis daily cost
  9. Pingback: viagra for sale
  10. Pingback: viagra 100mg
  11. Pingback: male ed pills
  12. Pingback: tadalafil
  13. Pingback: canada pharmacy
  14. Pingback: cialis online
  15. Pingback: Buy cialis
  16. Pingback: vardenafil online
  17. Pingback: vardenafil 10 mg
  18. Pingback: play casino online
  19. Pingback: slots online
  20. Pingback: short term loans
  21. Pingback: viagra pills
  22. Pingback: online casinos
  23. Pingback: betting sites 2018
  24. Pingback: generic for cialis
  25. Pingback: luther
  26. Pingback: Planet7
  27. Pingback: cialis internet
  28. Pingback: cialis buy
  29. Pingback: cialis generic
  30. Pingback: generic cialis
  31. Pingback: doubleu casino
  32. Pingback: casino real money
  33. Pingback: canadian viagra
  34. Pingback: sildenafil 100
  35. Pingback: tadalafil tablets
  36. Pingback:
  37. Pingback: viagra generic
  38. Pingback: cheap cialis
  39. Pingback: cheap Cialis 20 mg
  40. Pingback: order Cialis 60mg
  41. Pingback: viagra
  42. Pingback: Cialis 40 mg cheap
  43. Pingback: canadian pharmacy
  44. Pingback: lasix 40mg online
  45. Pingback: propecia 5mg nz
  46. Pingback: viagra prices
  47. Pingback: viagra online
  48. Pingback: abilify 10mg price
  49. Pingback: aldactone 100mg nz
  50. Pingback: amaryl 2mg usa
  51. Pingback: buy antivert 25mg
  52. Pingback: viagra with no pre
  53. Pingback: aricept 5mg cheap
  54. Pingback:
  55. Pingback: atarax 25mg pills
  56. Pingback: benicar 40mg price
  57. Pingback: cialis
  58. Pingback: ceftin prices
  59. Pingback: celebrex cost
  60. Pingback: ed solutions
  61. Pingback: buy cipro
  62. Pingback: claritin pharmacy
  63. Pingback: doubleu casino
  64. Pingback: viagra canada
  65. Pingback: rivers casino
  66. Pingback: online casino usa
  67. Pingback: slots online
  68. Pingback: online casino
  69. Pingback: buy cialis
  70. Pingback: cialis
  71. Pingback: cialis 20mg pills
  72. Pingback: tadalafil cialis
  73. Pingback: viagra online
  74. Pingback: buy cialis brand
  75. Pingback: levitra for women
  76. Pingback: india viagra price
  77. Pingback: Generic viagra
  78. Pingback: help my essay
  79. Pingback: essay writing
  80. Pingback: viagra tablet cost
  81. Pingback: write essay online
  82. Pingback: cleocin usa
  83. Pingback: clonidine pills
  84. Pingback: combivent pharmacy
  85. Pingback: cialis ohne ed
  86. Pingback: cialis online
  87. Pingback: compazine purchase
  88. Pingback: custom essay paper
  89. Pingback: tok essay help
  90. Pingback: writing the thesis
  91. Pingback: dapsone caps otc
  92. Pingback: Free viagra
  93. Pingback: viagra otc
  94. Pingback: ddavp purchase
  95. Pingback: doxycycline uk
  96. Pingback: elavil cost
  97. Pingback: buy Prednisone
  98. Pingback: medications online
  99. Pingback: generic cialis
  100. Pingback: otc cialis
  101. Pingback: imdur 60mg online
  102. Pingback: pharmacy
  103. Pingback: online viagra
  104. Pingback: natural viagra
  105. Pingback: viagra prices
  106. Pingback: viagra or cialis
  107. Pingback: viagra for men
  108. Pingback: you can look here
  109. Pingback: indocin online
  110. Pingback: zithromax online
  111. Pingback: lamisil uk
  112. Pingback: lopid generic
  113. Pingback: lopressor 50 mg nz
  114. Pingback: luvox 100mg price
  115. Pingback: viagra c20
  116. Pingback: micardis for sale
  117. Pingback: cheap Zovirax
  118. Pingback: motrin cheap
  119. Pingback: buy prevacid
  120. Pingback: prilosec canada
  121. Pingback: viagra
  122. Pingback: proscar for sale
  123. Pingback: protonix 20 mg nz
  124. Pingback: online viagra
  125. Pingback: provigil coupon
  126. Pingback: usa viagra prices
  127. Pingback: pulmicort price
  128. Pingback: amoxil pharmacy
  129. Pingback: buy pyridium
  130. Pingback: reglan online
  131. Pingback: zyrtec medicine
  132. Pingback: allegra 20855
  133. Pingback: robaxin 500mg uk
  134. Pingback: singulair purchase
  135. Pingback: tenormin 50 mg otc
  136. Pingback: thorazine for sale
  137. Pingback: valtrex medication
  138. Pingback: zanaflex 4 mg usa
  139. Pingback: buy zyprexa
  140. Pingback: zyvox cheap
  141. Pingback: tadalafil uk
  142. Pingback: buy aripiprazole
  143. Pingback: spironolactone nz
  144. Pingback: glimepiride uk
  145. Pingback: meclizine for sale
  146. Pingback: sildenafil generic
  147. Pingback: citalopram price
  148. Pingback: cephalexin cheap
  149. Pingback: buy cialis
  150. Pingback: clindamycin cost
  151. Pingback: warfarin 1mg otc
  152. Pingback: rosuvastatin cheap
  153. Pingback: cheap bisacodyl
  154. Pingback: cialis 20 mg cost
  155. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  156. Pingback: 141generic2Exare
  157. Pingback: bhosrcwr
  158. Pingback: generic tadalafil
  159. Pingback: best ed drugs
  160. Pingback: khkzlony
  161. Pingback: safe buy cialis
  162. Pingback: buy ed pills
  163. Pingback: top ed drugs
  164. Pingback: what cialis do
  165. Pingback: cheapest glipizide
  166. Pingback: buy lasix online
  167. Pingback: cialis comprar
  168. Pingback: prices cialis
  169. Pingback: buy viagra
  170. Pingback: flagyl online
  171. Pingback: cialis vidalista
  172. Pingback: viagra india
  173. Pingback: viagra kills
  174. Pingback: levofloxacin usa
  175. Pingback: viagra amazon
  176. Pingback: stromectol oral
  177. Pingback: reddit viagra
  178. Pingback: viagra creampie
  179. Pingback: slipped viagra mom
  180. Pingback: hims viagra
  181. Pingback: sildenafil results
  182. Pingback: free viagra
  183. Pingback: zithromax pill
  184. Pingback: viagra online usa
  185. Pingback: spotting on clomid
  186. Pingback: viagra prank
  187. Pingback: dapoxetine forum
  188. Pingback: viagra australia
  189. Pingback: viagra wiki
  190. Pingback: viagra substitute
  191. Pingback: vietnamese viagra
  192. Pingback: cialis generic
  193. Pingback: buy ed drugs
  194. Pingback: write dissertation
  195. Pingback: propecia men
  196. Pingback: cialis daily price
  197. Pingback: cheap viagra
  198. Pingback: cialis implant
  199. Pingback: cialis quid
  200. Pingback: free cialis
  201. Pingback: neurontin pi
  202. Pingback: cialis otc date
  203. Pingback: otc cialis when
  204. Pingback: cialis coupon 20mg
  205. Pingback: prozac vs paxil
  206. Pingback: plaquenil msds
  207. Pingback: meds from india
  208. Pingback: cialis pills
  209. Pingback: rx online cialis
  210. Pingback: clomid uk
  211. Pingback: generic ed pills
  212. Pingback: ed pills cheap
  213. Pingback: buy cialis toronto
  214. Pingback: Zakhar Berkut hd
  215. Pingback: 4569987
  216. Pingback: original cialis
  217. Pingback: buy doctor
  218. Pingback: news news news
  219. Pingback: psy
  220. Pingback: psy2022
  221. Pingback: projectio-freid
  222. Pingback: buy viagra pills
  223. Pingback: Tinder Seattle
  224. Pingback:
  225. Pingback: topvideos
  226. Pingback: video
  227. Pingback: lisinopril 60 mg
  228. Pingback: Ukrainskie-serialy
  229. Pingback: site
  230. Pingback: top
  231. Pingback: buy cialis drug
  232. Pingback: pumps for ed
  233. Pingback: viagra expiration
  234. Pingback: viagra sex
  235. Pingback: the best ed drug
  236. Pingback: viagra from india
  237. Pingback: cialis pharmacy uk
  238. Pingback: viagra price
  239. Pingback:
  240. Pingback: doxycycline mono
  241. Pingback: viagra price
  242. Pingback: how to fix ed
  243. Pingback:
  244. Pingback: blogery_i_dorogi
  245. Pingback: cheap pills online
  246. Pingback: priligy otc
  247. Pingback: keto pizza near me
  248. Pingback: ivermectin 3
  249. Pingback: top rated ed pills
  250. Pingback: how much is viagra
  251. Pingback: cialis rush
  252. Pingback: online pharmacy us
  253. Pingback: revive rx pharmacy
  254. Pingback: gay dating katy tx
  255. Pingback: pills for ed
  256. Pingback: prescription drugs
  257. Pingback: dating gay woman
  258. Pingback: viagra pills
  259. Pingback: gay dating italy
  260. Pingback: lipitor and liver
  261. Pingback: buy generic viagra
  262. Pingback: best male ed pills
  263. Pingback: best drugs for ed
  264. Pingback: purchase cialis
  265. Pingback: sildenafil 100mg
  266. Pingback: 1
  267. Pingback: purchase viagra
  268. Pingback: cialis 20mg daily
  269. Pingback: buy sildenafil
  270. Pingback: cheapest viagra
  271. Pingback: ivermectin 8000
  272. Pingback: how to buy cialis
  273. Pingback: ivermectin ebay
  274. Pingback: levitra viagra
  275. Pingback: albuterol mcg
  276. Pingback: horse ivermectin
  277. Pingback: ivermectin hiv
  278. Pingback: generis viagra
  279. Pingback: goodrx tadalafil
  280. Pingback: daily cialis
  281. Pingback: natural ed pills
  282. Pingback: sildenafil costs
  283. Pingback: buy viagra
  284. Pingback: dapoxetine pe
  285. Pingback: nolvadex steroids
  286. Pingback: ivermectin iv
  287. Pingback: homemade viagra
  288. Pingback: womens viagra
  289. Pingback: viagra ohne rezept
  290. Pingback: viagra cock
  291. Pingback: furosemide 20mg uk
  292. Pingback: neurontin generic
  293. Pingback: compra viagra
  294. Pingback: stromectol generic
  295. Pingback: female viagra
  296. Pingback: albuterol cost
  297. Pingback: hims viagra
  298. Pingback: viagra dosages
  299. Pingback: prednisone steroid
  300. Pingback: priligy price
  301. Pingback: modafinil 600mg
  302. Pingback: albuterol 25 mg
  303. Pingback: valtrex 500 mg

Leave a Reply